Budget 2019: Congress Slams Budget As ‘Old Wine In New Bottle’

Congress’ Spokesperson Randeep Surjewala asked if a ‘mundane jugglery of acronyms’ can pass off for vision for a ‘New India’.
Nirmala Sitharaman, India’s finance minister, reacts during a news conference in New Delhi, India. (Photographer: T. Narayan/Bloomberg)
Nirmala Sitharaman, India’s finance minister, reacts during a news conference in New Delhi, India. (Photographer: T. Narayan/Bloomberg)

The Bharatiya Janata Party on Friday hailed the union budget as one for a “new India”, which laid the foundation for an inclusive and progressive nation, while the Congress panned it as “old wine in new bottle”.

In this year’s budget, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman hiked tax on petrol and diesel, raised import duty on gold, levied additional surcharge on the super rich and brought a tax on high value cash withdrawals as she sought to spur growth with reduction in corporate tax and sops for housing, startups and electric vehicles.

BJP Chief and Union Home Minister Amit Shah said the finance minister presented a budget for a “new India” which laid the foundation for an inclusive and progressive nation, the rise of which was powered by the hard work of 130 crore countrymen.

“The budget gives wings to India’s farmers, youngsters, women and poor to fulfil their dreams,” he said in a series of tweets.

The budget highlighted the exemplary work in key sectors relating to the economy, housing, infrastructure and social sectors over the last five years and on this basis, ignited a spirit of hope that India could become a $5 trillion economy in the coming years, Shah said.

Budget 2019: Government Stresses On Massive Infrastructure Investments To Become $5-Trillion Economy

“The budget presented by Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman is a futuristic one. It provides a coherent roadmap for sectors that will drive growth and innovation among our citizens. The emphasis on clean energy and cashless transactions are also steps in the right direction,” he said in a tweet.

Criticising the budget, Congress leader in Lok Sabha Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury said it was just a repetition of “old promises”.

“They (the BJP) are talking about a new India, but it is simply old wine in a new bottle,” he told reporters outside Parliament.

He claimed that no new initiatives were announced by the government.

The Modi government has tried to project India as an ‘El Dorado’ (a place of fabulous wealth for all), but in reality the “pain of the economy is being experienced”, he said.

“There is no plan for employment generation, there is no distinct plan for giving any facilities to agriculture sector, labour sector. This is nothing but a litany of old promises,” Chowdhury said.

Congress’ Chief Spokesperson Randeep Surjewala also slammed the government over the budget proposals and asked if a “mundane jugglery of acronyms” can pass off for vision for a New India.

“An utterly lacklustre, nondescript, uninspiring and directionless Budget 2019. Zero on economic revival. Zero on rural growth. Zero on job creation. Zero on urban rejuvenation. Can a mundane jugglery of acronyms pass off for vision for a ‘new India’?” he said on Twitter.

“#Budget2019 so far—maximum intent, minimum content! maximum catchphrases, minimum catch-points,” he tweeted when the budget was being presented.

Another Congress spokesperson, Abhishek Manu Singhvi, wrote on the microblogging website—”Bailout plans for PSUs and moves like inheritance tax are Modi’s outing from the closet as the ultra left, vote seeking politician that he is. He got RWs (economic & political) to vote for him but his heart is only toward RW (right-wing) Polity not Economics.”

Budget 2019: Fiscal Deficit Math Relies On Ambitious Revenue, Dividend Targets

Shah said the budget set the stage for fulfilling the collective dreams of water for every citizen, ensuring power connectivity across India and boosting manufacturing, especially in the “sunrise” sectors.

The budget would enable India to become a more vibrant startup hub, he said.

Reacting to the Budget, Union minister Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi tweeted, “This budget is a 'gazette of new India' with a commitment to inclusive growth and good governance.”

Budget 2019: Key Takeaways From Nirmala Sitharaman’s Budget Speech
Get Regular Updates