Did Aadhaar Glitches Cause Half Of 14 Recent Jharkhand Starvation Deaths?
About 14 people died of starvation in Jharkhand over the last 10 months, according to the latest data from Right To Food campaign
On July 27, Rajendra Birhor, a 40-year-old Adivasi, starved to death in Ramgarh, a district in eastern Jharkhand. He belonged to a “particularly vulnerable tribal group” and should have had access to at least two welfare measures that could have saved his life: a pension and a ration card.
Like him, 13 others died of starvation in Jharkhand over the last 10 months, according to the latest available data from the Right To Food campaign, an advocacy group. They should have all benefited from Antodyay Anna Yojana, the food ration scheme meant for the poorest of poor in India.
In most cases, the Jharkhand government denied that deaths were caused by starvation (You can read those denials here, here and here). The state food and supply minister Saryu Roy has accused food activists, who see a link between starvation and these deaths, of “playing politics”.
à¤à¥à¤ à¤¸à¥ à¤®à¥à¤¤ à¤à¥ à¤ à¤«à¤µà¤¾à¤¹ à¤«à¥à¤²à¤¾à¤¨à¥ à¤µà¤¾à¤²à¥à¤ à¤à¥ à¤ªà¥à¤² à¤à¤ à¤°à¤¾à¤®à¤à¤¢ à¤à¥ à¤à¥à¤à¥à¤à¥ à¤®à¥ à¤à¥à¤² à¤à¤ à¤à¤¬ à¤®à¥à¤¤à¤ à¤à¥ à¤ªà¥à¤¤à¥à¤° à¤¨à¥ à¤®à¥à¤à¤¿à¤¯à¤¾ à¤à¤µà¤ à¤ à¤¨à¥à¤¯ à¤à¤ à¤à¥ à¤¸à¤¾à¤®à¤¨à¥ à¤à¤¹à¤¾ à¤à¤¿ à¤®à¥à¤¤ à¤à¥à¤ à¤¸à¥ à¤¨à¤¹à¥à¤ à¤¹à¥à¤ à¤¹à¥ à¤à¤¸à¤²à¤¿à¤¯à¥ à¤¶à¤µ à¤à¥ à¤à¤¼à¤¬à¥à¤° à¤¸à¥ à¤¨à¤¿à¤à¤¾à¤²à¤à¤° à¤ªà¥à¤¸à¥à¤à¤®à¤¾à¤°à¥à¤à¤® à¤à¤°à¤¾à¤¨à¥ à¤à¥ à¤à¤¼à¤°à¥à¤°à¤¤ à¤¨à¤¹à¥à¤ à¤¹à¥.à¤¯à¤¹ à¤¬à¤¾à¤¤ à¤à¤¸à¤¨à¥ à¤ªà¤¹à¤²à¥ à¤à¥ à¤à¤à¤¯à¥à¤ à¤à¥ à¤¸à¤¾à¤®à¤¨à¥ à¤à¤¹à¤¾ à¤¥à¤¾ à¤à¤¿à¤¸à¤à¤¾ à¤µà¥à¤¡à¤¿à¤¯à¥ à¤®à¥à¤à¥à¤¦ à¤¹à¥.— Saryu Roy (@roysaryu) June 18, 2018
à¤¤à¤¥à¤¾à¤à¤¥à¤¿à¤¤ à¤à¥à¤ à¤¸à¥ à¤®à¤°à¤¨à¥ à¤à¥ à¤à¤¼à¤¬à¤°à¥à¤ à¤ªà¤° à¤ à¤«à¤µà¤¾à¤¹ à¤à¤¡à¤¼à¤¾à¤¨à¥ à¤µà¤¾à¤²à¥ à¤à¤° à¤°à¤¾à¤à¤¨à¥à¤¤à¤¿ à¤à¥ à¤°à¥à¤à¥ à¤¸à¥à¤à¤à¤¨à¥ à¤µà¤¾à¤²à¥ à¤¬à¤¤à¤¾à¤¯à¥à¤ à¤à¥à¤à¥à¤à¥ à¤à¥ à¤¦à¥à¤°à¥à¤à¤¾à¤à¥à¤¯à¤ªà¥à¤°à¥à¤£ à¤®à¥à¤¤ à¤à¥ à¤¬à¤¾à¤°à¥ à¤®à¥ à¤¸à¤°à¤à¤¾à¤° à¤¸à¥ à¤à¥à¤¯à¤¾ à¤à¤¾à¤¹à¤¤à¥ à¤¹à¥à¤.à¤µà¥ à¤à¤¾à¤¹à¥à¤ à¤¤à¥ à¤®à¥à¤¤à¤ à¤¶à¤°à¥à¤° à¤à¥ à¤à¤¼à¤¬à¥à¤° à¤¸à¥ à¤¨à¤¿à¤à¤¾à¤²à¤à¤° à¤¸à¤°à¤à¤¾à¤° à¤ªà¥à¤¸à¥à¤à¤®à¤¾à¤°à¥à¤à¤® à¤à¤°à¤¾ à¤¦à¥à¤à¥.à¤¦à¥à¤§ à¤à¤¾ à¤¦à¥à¤§ à¤à¤° à¤ªà¤¾à¤¨à¥ à¤à¤¾ à¤ªà¤¾à¤¨à¥ à¤¹à¥ à¤à¤¾à¤¯à¥à¤à¤¾.— Saryu Roy (@roysaryu) June 16, 2018
à¤à¥à¤ à¤à¤° à¤®à¥à¤¤ à¤ªà¤° à¤°à¤¾à¤à¤¨à¥à¤¤à¤¿ à¤à¥ à¤°à¥à¤à¥ à¤¸à¥à¤à¤à¤¨à¥ à¤µà¤¾à¤²à¥ à¤°à¤¾à¤à¤¨à¥à¤¤à¤¾à¤à¤ à¤à¤° à¤¤à¤¥à¤¾à¤à¤¥à¤¿à¤¤ à¤¸à¤®à¤¾à¤à¤à¤°à¥à¤®à¤¿à¤¯à¥à¤ à¤à¥ à¤ à¤¸à¤²à¥ à¤à¤°à¤¾à¤¦à¥ à¤¬à¥à¤¨à¤à¤¼à¤¾à¤¬ à¤¹à¥à¤à¤à¥.à¤à¤¿à¤°à¤¿à¤¡à¥à¤¹ à¤à¤° à¤à¤¤à¤°à¤¾ à¤à¥ à¤ à¤¸à¤²à¤¿à¤¯à¤¤ à¤à¤¾à¤à¤ à¤®à¥à¤ à¤¸à¤¾à¤®à¤¨à¥ à¤ à¤à¤ à¤¹à¥.à¤«à¤¿à¤° à¤à¥ à¤¸à¥à¤µà¥¦ à¤¸à¤¾à¤µà¤¿à¤¤à¥à¤°à¥ à¤¦à¥à¤µà¥ à¤à¥ à¤à¤¾à¤à¤µ à¤à¤à¥ à¤°à¤¾à¤à¤¨à¥à¤¤à¤¿ à¤à¤°à¤¨à¥à¤µà¤¾à¤²à¥ à¤à¤¿à¤°à¤¦à¤¾à¤°à¥à¤ à¤à¥ à¤à¥à¤®à¤¿à¤à¤¾ à¤à¥ à¤à¤¾à¤à¤ à¤ à¤à¥ à¤à¥à¤ à¤¦à¤¿à¤¨ à¤à¤²à¤¤à¥ à¤°à¤¹à¥à¤à¥.— Saryu Roy (@roysaryu) June 8, 2018
IndiaSpend spoke to medical experts and social activists and found that the government response does not take into account two factors involving the links between malnutrition and starvation:
- Medically, these deaths are most likely due to infections and diseases. But prolonged malnutrition undermines the immune system, making the body prone to life-threatening infections;
- Starvation deaths are caused by a circle of poverty, government apathy and mandatory Aadhaar-ration-card integration, the lack of which deprives poor citizens of foodgrain they are entitled to under government schemes. Over a period of time, this results in malnutrition and death.
As the following table shows, in half the cases of starvation deaths reported from Jharkhand between September 2017 and July 2018, the deceased did not get the ration promised under the public distribution scheme and AAY.
The reason can be traced to the complications arising from the government mandate that ration cards and bank accounts be linked to Aadhaar, according to RTF campaigners. Aadhaar is a 12-digit unique identification number issued by the Indian government to every citizen and declared mandatory for various government welfare schemes.
Compulsory Linkage Of Aadhaar, Ration Card Continues, Despite Government Claims
In line with Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s vision of Digital India, the Jharkhand government in July 2016 transitioned to a “paperless” public distribution system, linked to individual Aadhaar numbers, as TheWire.in reported on July 18, 2017.
This system has two requirements: One, each person’s ration card has to be linked to their Aadhaar card; and two, each time a person wants ration under PDS, she must have biometric authentication done at a ‘point of sale’ machine, which then calculates eligibility. These machines are installed at PDS shops, where the dealer is supposed to authenticate each transaction.
In the two months after this Aadhaar-PDS linkage rule, in Ranchi district, ration-card holders received only 49 percent, or less than half, of their entitlement, according to an analysis of government data in July and August 2016 by development economist Jean Dreze.
The denial of foodgrain in Jharkhand has been reported before (here, here and here) and contested.
@roysaryu 'ji, Hope you take note of the story of this elderly woman. #UshaDevi lives in Ranchi, has #Aadhar & #RationCard & hasn't received her entitled grains from #PDS dealer in last #6MONTHS. A widow with both her sons dead, she can be 'face' of next #hungerdeath. @DC_Ranchi pic.twitter.com/JoIapecQPV— Hemant Soren (@HemantSorenJMM) June 9, 2018
In October 2017, the Jharkhand government claimed that Aadhaar is not mandatory for collecting foodgrain under PDS. However, district administrations in the state continue to adhere to the mandatory Aadhaar-ration card rule, according to RTF activists. This happened in Birhor’s case as well.
“Whatever the food minister or others may have told the media, the Jharkhand government never retracted its policy of compulsory linkage of ration cards with Aadhaar,” Dreze, also a visiting professor at Ranchi University, told IndiaSpend.
Activists are demanding that Aadhaar be delinked from all social-security schemes, including pensions, to save the poor from distress. Swati Narayan, an activist with the RTF in Ranchi, believes that the Aadhaar-ration integration requirement is behind the trail of starvation deaths in Jharkhand.
“The Jharkhand government needs to immediately universalise the rural ration eligibility from 86 percent to 100 percent of the population to ensure that no family is left out,” she said. “Additionally, excluded families should be immediately paid compensatory food security allowance for the last one year at least to prevent more horrific deaths due to starvation.”
Food and supply minister Roy insisted the 14 deaths were not related to starvation. “(They) can be attributed to the lack of ration cards, which is due to the lacunae in the government system, but they are not starvation deaths,” he told IndiaSpend. “RTF activists are hyper-ventilated (sic) people who are motivated against BJP [Bharatiya Janata Party] governments. I have not seen them commenting on the starvation deaths in Delhi.”
On July 27, three sisters were found dead under unexplained circumstances in Delhi’s Mandawali area. They possibly died of malnutrition or starvation, their postmortem reports said.
Given the inequalities in India’s population–India’s top 1 percent have 73 percent of India’s wealth–it is the government’s responsibility to provide food and nutrition to the marginalised, said Anjali Bhardwaj, an activist with the RTF in Delhi. “In Delhi and Jharkhand, the political will is lacking,” she said. “They may promise a lot of things, but on ground, the ill-thought move of PDS-Aadhaar linkage is starving people.”
Shamika Ravi, research director, Brookings India and a member of the Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council, countered that the emphasis should be on resolving systemic problems, not discrediting Aadhaar.
“Any exclusion error or case, where a person is being denied their benefits, is unacceptable and absolutely unjustified,” she told IndiaSpend. “However, the focus should be on strengthening the Aadhaar system. There are exclusions, yes, but what is still not clear to me is at exactly what stage is the problem (occuring)? Is it a problem at the point of authentication? Or there is a problem in how the PDS programme is linked with Aadhaar? Aadhaar has become a favorite whipping boy of many activists, but we need to identity the exact pain points and work on strengthening them.”
Dreze concurs partially with Ravi. “If Aadhaar is to be used at all for welfare schemes, it should be restricted to cases where it serves a clear purpose and where Aadhaar seeding can be done in a reliable and non-coercive manner,” he said. “Aadhaar-based biometric authentication should never be made compulsory.”
Starvation Deaths Must Be Established By Social, Medical History, Not Autopsy: Activists
In June 2018, the Jharkhand government made an autopsy a must for starvation deaths. But campaigners say this is not a fail-proof method for determining if death was caused by hunger.
“Historically, if post-mortems/autopsies have found a single grain of rice in bodies, they haven’t been classified as starvation deaths,” said Dipa Sinha, assistant professor at Ambedkar University, Delhi. “In Odisha, people have eaten mango kernels as they didn’t have anything else to eat. So, officially, they may not be starvation deaths medically, but I would classify them thus. In Jharkhand, the government has been hiding behind technicalities to absolve itself of responsibilities, but we cannot miss the fact that denial of food leads to chronic malnutrition.”
Narayan pointed out that the medical and social histories of those living in starvation zones are more important than autopsies to fix the reason for death. “After one year of screaming, the Jharkhand government has finally changed its definition of starvation, but has done little else,” she said.
In March, the Jharkhand government set up a nine-member committee which was supposed to define parameters by which starvation deaths can be established officially. However, the committee has missed its second deadline to compile the report and make it public, as the New Indian Express reported on July 31.
“From what I know, the committee has analysed information and (is) almost done with its report,” Jharkhand minister Roy said. “It will release the final report very soon. However, I cannot comment on the exact date as it is an autonomous committee and they will take their own time and decisions.”
There is no need to set up a committee to define starvation as a lot of literature and research already exists on the subject, said NC Saxena, former secretary of the erstwhile Planning Commission and former commissioner of a Supreme Court-monitored committee on food and hunger. “In my experience, in Jharkhand, the government usually under-reports starvation and malnutrition levels,” he said. “They should rather focus their energies on collecting proper data and on how severely malnourished children and people can be identified and intervened (with).”
Malnutrition And Infections: A Two-Way Causal Association
In September 2017, an 11-year-old girl Santoshi died allegedly due to starvation. She and her family did not get foodgrain because their Aadhaar cards had not being linked to ration cards. In response to criticism over Santoshi’s death, Amit Malviya, incharge of the BJP’s information technology cell, cited a district official’s report and claimed that her death was due to malaria, and not starvation.
11-year old girl in Jharkhand died because of malaria and not because her family was denied ration. DCâs report enclosed. Fact check anyone? pic.twitter.com/8WULhfnr4L— Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) October 17, 2017
However, experts told IndiaSpend that malnutrition and disease are so interlinked that it is hard to separate the two. Undernourished children principally die of common infections and immune defects, according to this 2016 paper.
“Lack of adequate nutrition or undernutrition leads to infections which can be life-threatening,” said Bhavna Dhingra, a pediatrician with the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bhopal. “These infections can reduce the appetite of children, which severely affects the already precarious nutrition situation.”
Giridhara R Babu, an epidemiologist and additional professor at the Public Health Foundation of India, explained how malnutrition works to weaken the body: “In the shorter term, malnutrition leads to weight loss due to depletion of fat and muscle mass, including some of the organs. In the long run, prolonged decreased dietary intake leads to a reduction in functional energy reserves and changes in body composition.”
Starvation itself rarely results in death which is usually caused by infections among those lacking in malnutrition, said Nehal Vaidya, a pediatrician from Bhuj, Gujarat.
“In case of a reported case of child malnutrition, where a child has stayed hungry for many days, first, a clinical assessment should be done to analyse the child’s body and hunger and then the appropriate intervention should be done and the parents should be counselled on how to feed the child,” she said. “However, in rural and urban areas, lack of infrastructure is a big problem. You need specialist doctors, paediatricians, nutritionists and public health experts to deal with such cases.”
Severely malnourished children in state-run malnutrition treatment centres in Jharkhand showed poor recovery, most demonstrated poor weight gain, and a high number of illnesses were reported post- discharge, according to this 2018 paper which examined the efficacy of an MTC in Jharkhand. Malnourishment at an early age can have long-term consequences, affecting an individual’s motor, sensory, cognitive, social and emotional development, as IndiaSpend reported on July 22, 2017.
There is a 90 percent shortfall of specialists (surgeons, obstetricians and gynaecologists, doctors, and paediatricians) across community health centres in Jharkhand, according to the Rural Health Statistics 2017. Other than specialists, India is short of doctors in general. India’s doctor-to-population ratio of 1:1,674 is 75 percent lower than Argentina and 70 percent lower than the U.S., as IndiaSpend reported on November 16, 2016.
The CHCs constitute the secondary level of health care and provide specialist care to patients referred from primary health centres, four of which feed into each CHC, serving roughly 80,000 people in tribal, hill or desert areas and about 1.2 lakh on the plains.
Devanik Saha is a doctoral candidate at the Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex, UK. He also works as consultant with Policy & Development Advisory Group, Delhi
This copy has been published in arrangement with IndiaSpend.